Council of the Learned 2012: Divisional Playoffs

Forecast for Denver:
High: 21 F
Wind Chill: near 0 F

OMG, Manning is a cooked goose in cold weather! (Don't you love my mixed imagery?)

The Guardian, of all places, has a good story on this.

Manning, himself, is noted for an atrocious playoff record in games with the temperature below 40 degrees. He's 0-3 in these games and a combined 64 for 120 for 612 yards with one touchdown and seven interceptions. His passer rating was below 40 in two of those games.

But wait!

These were all games on the road. Teams win only 40% of their road playoff games. Two of them were against the New England Patriots. Road teams in New England when Bill Belichick is at the helm have only won 17% of their games. Manning losing these games is not really surprising.

And there's more!

You get a completely different picture of Manning when you examine his cold games during the regular season.

In 13 regular season games where the temperature was 21 to 40 degrees fahrenheit, Manning had a quarterback rating of 94.5. That's little different from his 95.7 quarterback rating in games overall. Manning's completion percentage in these games was 64.7 and he threw for an average of 8.0 yards per attempt. That's on par with the 65.2% completion percentage in all games and 7.6 yards per attempt.

Did I mention that he had 23 touchdowns and only 13 interceptions in these cold games? In fact, even in the one game he played below 20 degrees, he still was 14 for 18 on pass attempts.

Myself, I think the home teams sweep.

The closest games will probably be in the NFC.

Atlanta's run defense (and defense in general) has been pointed out as a weakness. The yardage numbers agree. The Falcons have been getting by on scheme and on turnovers. They're 5th in turnover margin, I believe, and 5th-best in points allowed.

Seattle has a short week, a lot of travel and a rookie QB. This will help Atlanta's rested defense, which returns safety William Moore. Also, Seattle suffered a big loss at defensive end.

And emotionally, how much do they have left? Pete Carroll is great at getting his guys up for a game. But there's no way they'll match Atlanta's intensity.

Players feed on disrespect and the whole world has been pooping on the birds. Expect a response.

For reasons which are beyond my limited understanding, Green Bay has not been its usual impressive self on offense. For that reason alone, I see them losing in San Francisco.

You guys finally bucked a disturbing trend, too many are picking the Packers. Thank you! If everyone is seeing things the same way that's not good.

I can see a 20 point win, a 20 point loss and just about everything in between.

Also the OL crack is somewhat deserved, but not for the reasons you might think.

In the first meeting, it was Ahmad Brooks and Carlos Rogers who did much of the damage (Brooks had 3 QB hits to go with a sack, Rogers was 1/1). Smith and Smith were handled pretty well by Newhouse and Lang. Sitton and Bulaga both had rough days. Sitton has mostly regained his form while Bulaga was a yoyo before heading to IR. On the other side, Joe Staley was abused by Matthews and then went on to have a pretty good season. The big question marks this time around are Don Barclay, who has been fine at home and a bit shaky on the road (noise?) and maybe EDS with the calls. Even if Staley struggles with Clay, Kaepernick is a lot more mobile than Smith and far less likely to take a sack (he could be pushed into doing something silly, which is the hope I'm sure).

On the flip side, Jarrett Bush isn't going to be playing CB in this game unless disaster strikes. Smith and Perry aren't going to be covering RBs and TEs on the intermediate routes. I'm anticipating that the 49ers will try to find a way to exploit Woodson covering Vernon Davis and/or Delanie Walker.

And don't forget that the whole game could come down to one of the shaky kicker club members on either side.

I can't wait, this is going to be great, either way it turns out.

Update: An even more detailed look at the Divisional Round with an accompanying Preview Podcast now in the blog section.

http://footballpros.com/entry.php/229-Manning-Up

The interesting facet to the divisional games every year is if there will be any visible rust by the top seeds due to the week off. As Rich mentioned, home teams win in this round just over 75% of the time. However, dating back to 2005, there have been at least 2 road teams pulling off the upset in this round in 5 of 7 seasons, including 2008, which featured 3 road teams (Baltimore, Arizona, Philadelphia) all winning their contests. In total, road teams are a respectable 13-15 over that 7 year stretch.

Chalk Picks

On paper, the Denver-Baltimore game seems to be the least fascinating of the 4 games. I fully expect this to be a defensive struggle. Denver was tied for the top spot in fewest yards per play, and finished 2nd in yards allowed per rush. To close the season, the Denver defense was arguably the most dominating defense in all of football. Baltimore meanwhile saw their defense improve greatly down the stretch. Both Denver and Baltimore were 2 of the 5 most difficult teams on opposing QBs over the last 5 games. But while Baltimore's run defense improved late, it's still the squeakiest wheel that will likely be exploited in this game. As was mentioned above, Peyton Manning is nearly as good in the cold weather during the regular season as he is in a controlled climate. But during the postseason, his numbers drop dramatically. Whether that means he's a poor cold-weather QB, or just tends to lay an egg in the playoffs is up to one's own interpretation, but it's tough to argue with a 6/9 TD/INT ratio in 9 road playoff games. Especially for a guy who otherwise averages nearly 2 TD passes per game throughout his career. I like Denver to take a low-scoring affair, controlling the ball with a solid ground attack, and just enough game-management from Manning, who will be smart enough to understand his own limitations. Denver 17 Baltimore 6

I love everything about the 49ers-Packers game. SF almost seemed bored at the end of the year. Perhaps the Seattle game was their wakeup call. And I'm not sure why, but I'm not sold on GB this year. They seem to be a bit inconsistent. I feel like SF will be able to bully the GB defense with Frank Gore, opening additional lanes for Kaepernick, and letting SF control when they take their shots to Crabtree, Davis, and their one shot with Moss. I think DuJuan Harris is the biggest key to this game. If he can give GB a consistent threat on the ground, and allow them to not have to be one-dimensional, then GB probably wins. However, I think SF limits GB's rush attack, and wins this game. San Francisco 27 Green Bay 20


ATD-

Seattle is the trendy pick, and rightly so. But Wilson is still a rookie QB on a that did struggle on the road this year. Plus, Atlanta gets the rare opportunity to invoke the "nobody believes in us" card as the 1 seed at home. Honestly, I have no idea how a porous ATL run defense shuts down Marshawn Lynch, but I have a feeling they find a way to get a big play out of Julio Jones, make a couple of plays defensively, and pull away late. Atlanta 27 Seattle 17

Houston isn't as bad as they showed vs. NE or GB this year. The last game with NE got out of hand early, but Houston was able to move the ball on NE. After NE's first TD, Houston drove down the field until Schaub threw a bad INT in the end zone. NE followed with a long TD to Brandon Lloyd, and the rout was on. Houston will be highly motivated, as is already evidenced by Arian Foster's twitter feed. I feel like Watt will be able to disrupt Brady, and I'm not sure NE will have an answer for Foster. Plus, I'm seeing a gigantic game from Andre Johnson. *Upset Special* Houston 31 New England 27

Good work Wax! Love the fact that the Guardian's NFL writer uses stats as ridiculously as an American writer!

"Here's a fact. Now here's a fact that explains why the previously stated fact may be meaningless."

Guy should work with Aaron Schatz...

I'm not alone in smelling potential beatdowns in the AFC and two epics in the NFC.

Get set for the Broncos/Patriots and Packers in Atlanta next week.

Originally Posted by Pruitt

I'm not alone in smelling potential beatdowns in the AFC and two epics in the NFC.

Get set for the Broncos/Patriots and Packers in Atlanta next week.

For me, the toughest game to pick is Packers-SF. All the others, I feel pretty confident about. I've opted for 49ers because neither team seems to be in peak form and I think the home field will decide it. I took 49ers in my playoff survivor for the NFC because I want to save Atlanta. Always a risky way to go about a survivor pool.

Wow, I'm the only person who picked the Ravens? Really, no one else thinks that a team that was missing 8 starters the last time they played Denver can't upset a Broncos team who has played 1, maybe 2, quality opponents in 3 months?

Now, more than before, I really hope the Ravens win!

Originally Posted by Amy

Wow, I'm the only person who picked the Ravens? Really, no one else thinks that a team that was missing 8 starters the last time they played Denver can't upset a Broncos team who has played 1, maybe 2, quality opponents in 3 months?

Now, more than before, I really hope the Ravens win!

Looks like your wish may be granted!

Well, I switched my survivor pick to Green Bay. (I had the NFC, so could wait until kickoff.)

YAY Ravens!

I screamed more in this game then for any Pats game this year.

What a game, instant classic.

Double OT. Amazing plays on both teams. Just incredible.

Oh, and I guess Denver won't win the Super Bowl this year. So sorry to all the talking heads who crowned them in November.

Originally Posted by Amy

Wow, I'm the only person who picked the Ravens? Really, no one else thinks that a team that was missing 8 starters the last time they played Denver can't upset a Broncos team who has played 1, maybe 2, quality opponents in 3 months?

Now, more than before, I really hope the Ravens win!

I didn't think the ravens couldn't upset the Broncos, but in my picks I go with logic. Hottest team in the AFC vs the coldest team in the AFC pre playoffs. Broncos were better on both offense and defense, plus they had homefield. Logical to make that pick.

However, my gut and emotions told me the Broncos were going to lose, and lose because of manning. It's why I picked the ravens in my upset special. Manning was exactly what I believed he was..

Now if the pats win vs the Texans it sets up a pats vs ravens afcg. The ravens are patriot kryptonite, especially in the playoffs, especially at Gillette...

The pats will be favored, but im likely to go with my gut again.. add in some extra special ray ray retirement magic, and it makes me picking the upset quite likely, just not necessarily in the council picks

I have to say that I'm amazed at the transformation in Baltimore's defense. I thought a gimpy Suggs and Lewis wouldn't help them much. I was wrong as wrong can be. Even when it was gassed the defense played well.

Originally Posted by wxwax

I have to say that I'm amazed at the transformation in Baltimore's defense. I thought a gimpy Suggs and Lewis wouldn't help them much. I was wrong as wrong can be. Even when it was gassed the defense played well.

they gave up 35 points, no?

Originally Posted by Bengals1181

they gave up 35 points, no?

No. They gave up 21 points.

Originally Posted by wxwax

I have to say that I'm amazed at the transformation in Baltimore's defense. I thought a gimpy Suggs and Lewis wouldn't help them much. I was wrong as wrong can be. Even when it was gassed the defense played well.

A lot of players turned their seasons around during the second half of the season on the defense. Paul Kruger is the best example; a lot of people really don't realize that he was a liability on defense throughout the first half of the year. But also Cary Williams, Dannell Ellerbe, and Arthur Jones had noticeable improvement in their play. Jimmy Smith's injury was really a blessing in disguise as it put Corey Graham into the starting lineup and he's been great. Pernell McPhee returning from his injury also really helped.

Originally Posted by KabaModernFan

No. They gave up 21 points.

thanks. I didn't watch most of the game so didn't want to assume all 35 were from them.

kaba, what's your thoughts on the future of Boldin as far as being a cap casualty? Some Bengals fans are interested in maybe bringing him in for a year while guys like Sanu and Jones mature.

Originally Posted by Bengals1181

thanks. I didn't watch most of the game so didn't want to assume all 35 were from them.

No problem. The other two touchdowns were the ones scored on kick returns by Holliday.