• ABC-BPH, KC's Beautiful Joe Pisarcik Tribute, and Other Random Thoughts From Week 2


    Following each football weekend, I’ll be posting random thoughts and reactions focusing mainly on the NFL, but also touching on college football and perhaps some other random topics along the way. Please share your comments below, reacting to anything written here, or any other observations you have from this weekend’s action.

    -The easiest rule to forget, especially after week 1, is that usually there is nothing that tells us less about a team than getting blown out. This holds true even with teams that we perceive to be bad. Tampa, Jacksonville, Oakland, Cleveland, and Minnesota are all teams that looked awful in week 1. All 5 finished last year with a losing record, Jacksonville with only 3 wins, and Oakland, Cleveland, and Tampa in last place, with the expectation that they’ll repeat that finish again this year. While that may still be the case, all 5 rebounded with a victory this week, with Minnesota (Detroit) and Oakland (Baltimore) defeating 2014 playoff teams, and Tampa rebounding to impressively defeat division rival New Orleans on the road.

    -The Redskins don’t quite fit this bill because they did not get blown out last week, but they also didn’t look very good in their loss to Miami. The Rams were coming off a big win over Seattle (a team they always seem to play tough), and the consensus was that the Redskins had little shot on Sunday. However, as our own Matt Kocsan pointed out within the W&L thread (BTW- great work as always, guys), “beating the Seahawks and then losing to the Redskins is the most Jeff Fisher’s Mustache thing ever.” Say what you want about the Redskins, but the defense looks to be much improved, Matt Jones looks like he has a chance to be dynamic, and Kirk Cousins only threw 4 incompletions in his 27 attempts. Maybe the Redskins finishing at the bottom of the NFC East isn’t a foregone conclusion.

    -By the same token, we can’t overrate San Francisco’s performance. The schedule did them no favors on Sunday. Playing the late game Monday, then traveling across country 5 ½ days later to play at 10:00 their time against a team with 10 days of rest is about as bad a draw as can be drawn. They are almost certainly not going to the playoffs this year, but they will be tougher than most people think.

    -If the Bears are bad with Jay Cutler, what are they without him?

    -The National League playoffs are going to be ridiculous fun. Unless, of course, the Pirates lose in the Wild Card game, in which case I’m pretty sure MLB will just immediately halt their season until next year.

    -The Cowboys losing Tony Romo is obviously a huge blow. They’ve now lost Romo and Bryant after letting DeMarco Murray go in Free Agency. Factor in the inevitable Sean Lee injury (who really is fantastic when he’s on the field), and the Cowboys would be in trouble in just about any division. Except the NFC East look pretty pathetic after 2 weeks. I’m not quite ready to write the Eagles off yet, but them sleepwalking through Sunday’s game was inexplicable. Now, if Dallas can merely tread water through the meat of the season, by the time (hopefully) Romo and Bryant are back, they’ll be in position at the end of the season to once again play for the NFC East championship.

    -Seattle’s defense is still good, but it’s no longer the shutdown unit we’ve seen in recent seasons. Is Kam Chancellor really that important, or are the Seahawks taking a step back this year?

    -Ohio State and Michigan State have jumped to 1 and 2 in the AP poll, the first time B1G schools have been ranked 1,2 since 2006 (Michigan/Ohio State). Each will be heavy favorites in every game leading up to their showdown in Columbus on November, 21.

    -Don’t let the 43-37 final throw you, Ole Miss thoroughly whipped Alabama in Tuscaloosa. They’ve shot up to #3, and are suddenly the clear favorite in what may be a somewhat shaky SEC West.

    -“It’s so hard to say goodbye to yesterday…” It’s time to break out the Boyz II Men and serenade the Josh McCown era in Cleveland. “The good times that made us laugh outweigh the bad.” It was fun while it lasted. Thank you for everything, Josh.

    -The Red Zone and Fantasy Zone channels are fantastic for any number of reasons-- none bigger than the fact that it allows me to avoid those Cialis commercials, and the ensuing awkward conversation with my 9 year old. That alone is worth the price of subscription.

    -LSU RB Leonard Fournette is a beast. Cal QB Jared Goff is also the real deal.

    -File the name Saquan Barkley into the back of your mind. The Penn State Freshman RB went for 21/195/2 against Rutgers this weekend, and is a future star.

    -When the schedule was released in April, I’ll admit that I was more than a little puzzled when I saw that the Chiefs planned to honor Joe Pisarcik mid-game during their home opener. Kudos to the Chiefs for absolutely crushing that tribute.



    Teams That Impressed-
    New England- I thought that Bills defense was supposed to be New England’s kryptonite.

    Pittsburgh- Name the last QB/WR combo as unstoppable as Roethlisberger/Brown. Oh, and that front 7 is looking dynamic for the first time in 4-5 years.

    Green Bay- On New England’s level in their ability to makeshift a dynamic offense no matter the pieces.

    Tampa- Maybe New Orleans isn’t actually any good, but for a rookie QB to rebound in that manner on the road is awfully impressive.

    Atlanta- They have to be considered a top 3 team in the NFC after 2 weeks.

    Notre Dame, THE U, Ole Miss- All 3 looked dominant before holding on late. Ole Miss is going to win the SEC, Miami may put up double-digit wins, and despite losing their QB and RB, Notre Dame remains a legit playoff contender.


    Teams That Depressed
    Baltimore- They’ll probably be fine, but they just let Derek Carr carve up their defense.

    Philly- The only thing missing from Chip Kelly during that game was this…


    Detroit- I’ll admit that I haven’t seen much from this game, but at least 54 dropbacks (I’m not sure how many of his 4 carries were designed runs, but I’m assuming not all?) and 12 non-QB rushes. Stafford had 20 yards on his 4 carries, while the rest of the team had 18 on their 12. Novel thought- what about getting Abdullah (7 offensive touches) the rock? I thought there was a Lombardi running this offense...

    Comments 28 Comments
    1. Patrick Sullivan's Avatar
      Shame on you, Ndamukong Suh.
    1. Matt Kocsan's Avatar
      I like it. I'll play.

      --Nothing tells you less about a team than a blowout is a pretty good dictum, actually. Of course, it does kind of tell you something if a team gets blown out, and then comes back twice and has a legitimate chance to win the game, as Alabama did against Ole Miss. Twice.

      --In that vein, Alabama trailed virtually the whole game, but I think--given that their quarterback situation isn't exactly settled and they're replacing all those receivers--it would have made more sense to ride Derrick Henry more than they did.

      --Could you elaborate on why you think Miami was particularly impressive? I did not get to see this game, and giving away a 23-point lead in the final eleven minutes of the fourth quarter seems like fairly bad news to me. Now, they probably looked pretty decent building that lead, but still.

      --This brings the all-time good performances of Kirk Cousins to, like, two, doesn't it? On a scale of 1 to Catholicism, I have about as much faith in the Washington Redskins as I do in the Cleveland Browns. That's not a lot.

      --I know that we're talking about Brandon Weeden here, but I've done the math and I think Dallas is actually going to be okay. Look, Dallas is 2-0, which gives them a two-game lead on everyone in that division except Washington, who, as I just said, I still think is terrible; they currently hold tie-breakers on Philadelphia and New York, by the way, so it's really a three-game lead at present.

      Bryant is out somewhere between six weeks and two months, I believe. That is okay, Brandon Weeden was in Cleveland, so it's not like he's used to having real wide receivers on his teams anyway. Romo is out for about eight-to-ten weeks, but given Romo's track record, I think that if there's any possible way the dude can play, he's going out on the field. Let's call it eight weeks. Dallas gets a bye in that span, so they play seven games; if they win two of them, they can probably still survive in this division, and if they win three then they should be golden. They won't beat New England or Seattle, but they have New Orleans, Philadelphia (again), the Giants (again), and Tampa Bay on this schedule. I think Dallas can figure out a way at least to split with those four, or even steal a third random one.

      Or maybe we're just about to find how bad Pat Shurmur and Rob Chudzinski were at coaching, which you know I'm already fully prepared for.

      --I think Baltimore has some serious issues. Their running game is pretty plodding and they need to find a receiver in the worst way. Steve Smith has had a great career, but he's 36 and he's short. Who is the guy on the other end of the Joe Flacco chuck-and-pray-and-wave-your-arms-and-beg-for-a-pass-interference-penalty Offense (trademark pending), anyway? I remember watching Marlon Brown in a high school all-star game back in like 2009, and I have no idea why a guy who is 6'5", 220 lbs., didn't see more of the ball at Georgia. He looks exactly like what Baltimore needs to me. Throw that guy the ball, maybe.
    1. Hoser's Avatar
      From the Department of Misery Loves Company:
      The Rams lost to the Redskins.
      The Seahawks are 0-2.
      Tony Romo is out with a clavicle.
      Not a bad day to be a Niner fanboy.

      Oh...and after watching the replay of Mike Mitchell dive at Carlos Hyde's knee...uhh...super cheap but not that unexpected given the financial penalty associated with getting anywhere near a players noggin. This seems more dangerous than a hit to the head, to me.

      http://www.sportsgrid.com/nfl/vine-c...t-to-the-knee/


      I've watched the NFL the majority of my life. I don't know what a catch is.
    1. hobbes27's Avatar
      I just love the insanity being posted as QBs to replace Tony Romo. I don't think Cowboy nation has much faith in Brandon Weedon. I would love for either of these things to happen, so that the circus can come to Dallas.

      http://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nfl/...yPnL?li=AA54yf

      http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/eye-on-...-with-romo-out
    1. Matt Kocsan's Avatar
      Quote Originally Posted by Hoser View Post
      Oh...and after watching the replay of Mike Mitchell dive at Carlos Hyde's knee...uhh...super cheap but not that unexpected given the financial penalty associated with getting anywhere near a players noggin. This seems more dangerous than a hit to the head, to me.
      The thing is, he's a ball carrier there. There's no penalty or fine if Hyde ducks when Mitchell goes for a shoulder wrap-up and the defender ends up cracking the guy in the skull. The only reason to go for the knee there is because you're an ***hole.
    1. Hoser's Avatar
      True. Especially the last part.
      However, given the vagaries surrounding what is allowed and what isn't, I can see tacklers conditioning themselves to always go low. I know I would. But just to be clear...he is still an ***hole.
    1. Matt Kocsan's Avatar
      ...and look, I'm not saying every hit that ends up in the area of the knee itself is inherently dirty. I mean, if you play football when you're ten years old, you'll start hearing that 'the low man wins.' It tends to be true in both blocking and tackling, and that area between the knee and the waist is the perfect spot for a sound, fundamental form-tackle. Sometimes, things happen and a guy ends up low, or from a practical point of view, someone is trying to put a man three times his size down on the turf out in the open field with no support around him and errors on the side of going low. That's not what is happening here. Hyde is held up and pretty much on one leg. There's no traffic around him and any solid push is going to put this guy on the ground. There's just no need for that.
    1. Brian Williams's Avatar
      Quote Originally Posted by Matt Kocsan View Post
      --Could you elaborate on why you think Miami was particularly impressive? I did not get to see this game, and giving away a 23-point lead in the final eleven minutes of the fourth quarter seems like fairly bad news to me. Now, they probably looked pretty decent building that lead, but still.
      Miami's standard in my mind was different than the standard for Ole Miss and Notre Dame. It's not like they're likely competing for a playoff berth like the other two schools should be, but they are fighting for a 9-10 win season and a place in the ACC Championship. Much like ND and Ole Miss, the way they built a big lead was impressive. They clearly need to do a better job of not letting their opponent off the mat, but I think they'll learn from it. And when they did get to OT, even with Nebraska having all the momentum, Miami creates the TO then puts them away, which showed a bit of resiliency.

      It's not vintage Miami by any stretch, but it's a start, and was a much needed win for Al Golden.
    1. Brian Williams's Avatar
      Yes, when seeing the Mitchell hit live, it looked awfully dirty. Not all that surprising to be honest, he's a pretty dirty player. The article you listed lumped the entirety of the Steelers franchise into it, mentioning coaching, and I don't think that's fair. I'm sure they're coaching much like Matt explained. Mitchell just has a tendency to play recklessly and take things one step too far.

      Thankfully Hyde came back into the game, so it looks like he's avoided any long term, or even short term damage.
    1. Matt Kocsan's Avatar
      So, Rapoport is reporting that the Saints believe Drew Brees's shoulder will sideline him for a couple weeks. So, that Luke McCown--Brandon Weeden showdown on Sunday Night Football on October 4 is going to be pretty intense.

      Quote Originally Posted by Me View Post
      Bryant is out somewhere between six weeks and two months, I believe. That is okay, Brandon Weeden was in Cleveland, so it's not like he's used to having real wide receivers on his teams anyway. Romo is out for about eight-to-ten weeks, but given Romo's track record, I think that if there's any possible way the dude can play, he's going out on the field. Let's call it eight weeks. Dallas gets a bye in that span, so they play seven games; if they win two of them, they can probably still survive in this division, and if they win three then they should be golden. They won't beat New England or Seattle, but they have New Orleans, Philadelphia (again), the Giants (again), and Tampa Bay on this schedule. I think Dallas can figure out a way at least to split with those four, or even steal a third random one.
      So, that's one, I'll bet. All Dallas has to do is win one or two more.
    1. Nancy's Avatar
      -The National League playoffs are going to be ridiculous fun. Unless, of course, the Pirates lose in the Wild Card game, in which case I’m pretty sure MLB will just immediately halt their season until next year.
      I wasn't aware baseball was still going on. You mean they keep playing even after the Reds are out of the race???? Who knew?

      I guess technically the Colts weren't blown out last week, but if you watched (or listened, as I did) to the game, you know they were never in it and looked wretched in every aspect of the game. Wretched. There is a lot of negativity spiraling around that organization, and I can't help but think it will continue to affect the team's play. Popular opinion seems to be that Pagano is out after this season regardless, because he and Grigson don't play well together. No idea how much truth there is to that, and as we know, winning just makes everything better, so if the team gets on a roll we'll probably hear no more of it. Prior to the season, I heard many people in the national media predicting the Colts would go to the Superbowl. I was dubious even before they practically put a gold jacket on Tyrod Taylor last week. They got rid of one old WR, and brought in another. They ditched some running backs and brought in Frank Gore, but have yet to find anyone who knows how to run block, and they still can't protect Luck. The defensive backfield was and is inconsistent. Vontae Davis is always ready for Tom Brady, but even he is an up-and-down player. Robert Mathis was out all last year and he's about my age, I think; believe me, when you're over 50 it's hard to get back in shape All of which is to say that I don't think that debacle against the Bills proves that the Colts are horrid any more than it proves that the Bills and future HOF QB Tyrod Taylor are really that good. I don't know that the Bills' loss to the Pats proved much; but if the Colts lose to the Jets tonight, it's gonna be a long season for Big Blue.
    1. Matt Kocsan's Avatar
      Even if the Colts lose tonight (I kind of think they will) and they are not that good this year, I just have a hard time seeing them skipping the playoffs, Nancy. I still think 9-7 is going to be more than enough to win that division when it's all over.
    1. Nancy's Avatar
      Quote Originally Posted by Matt Kocsan View Post
      Even if the Colts lose tonight (I kind of think they will) and they are not that good this year, I just have a hard time seeing them skipping the playoffs, Nancy. I still think 9-7 is going to be more than enough to win that division when it's all over.
      I don't know, Matt...the offense looks in complete disarray. Penalties, fumbles, drops, missed blocks. Even if the division continues to be weak, I'm not sure the Colts are even the best of a bad lot this season. Luck is such an incredible talent, I'd hate to spend the next several years watching a great quarterback play for a team that sucks season upon season because the team doesn't know how to draft or sign free agents. Is this the overreaction thread??? LOL!!
    1. Matt Kocsan's Avatar
      Let's take a look at the Colts' offensive line, guys:


      You're not wrong, Nancy. The Colts should struggle against any team with a good front seven. I just don't see the Texans or Jaguars or Titans being able to win enough games to supplant them, though.
    1. Brian Williams's Avatar
      Quote Originally Posted by Matt Kocsan View Post
      Let's take a look at the Colts' offensive line, guys:


      You're not wrong, Nancy. The Colts should struggle against any team with a good front seven. I just don't see the Texans or Jaguars or Titans being able to win enough games to supplant them, though.
      The correct answer is Jacksonville.

      Wait, what?
    1. Matt Kocsan's Avatar
      Quote Originally Posted by Brian Williams View Post
      The correct answer is Jacksonville.

      Wait, what?
      Oh dear. Let's talk about this on October 4. The Jags have opened at +13.5 at New England for this week and they go to Indy next week. I think they've got to have that Indianapolis game and I'd like to see them look decent against the Pats, too. They get Tampa Bay after that, so... if they're 3-2 at that point, I'll start to listen.
    1. Matt Kocsan's Avatar
      Ray Lewis, multi-tasking on the MNF set:

    1. Amy's Avatar
      The Cowboys have reportedly traded for Matt Cassell.
    1. ScottDCP's Avatar
      Quote Originally Posted by Amy View Post
      The Cowboys have reportedly traded for Matt Cassell.
      Yeah. About that. Doug Whaley, the drunken teenager gambling on a riverboat, gave Cassell to Dallas with a seventh for a fifth.

      So the Dallas 2016 5th round pick cost Buffalo the 2015 4th, 2016 4th and 7th, and a good veteran backup who was describec by the coaches as "the glue in the quarterback room," and the key to helping Taylor and Manuel learning how to be pros.
    1. Ragar's Avatar
      -Seattle’s defense is still good, but it’s no longer the shutdown unit we’ve seen in recent seasons. Is Kam Chancellor really that important, or are the Seahawks taking a step back this year?

      I pulled this out because it deserves it's own little position: YES, safeties are that important. After the Packers lost Nick Collins(neck injury-OoF), it took until last year for Clinton-Dix to begin to approximate what a good to great safety can do for you. (and Collins was much better the Clinton-Dix). The ability to control the middle of the field forces not great QB's to make harder throws to outside or perfect throws to the middle, and we see that most qb's cant do this. Onc ethe middle of the field opens up, great qb's can just pick you apart.