Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: I do not know whether to be excited about Buffalo selecting Shaq Lawson

  1. #1
       
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Rochester, NY
    Posts
    4,586
    Blog Entries
    21

    I do not know whether to be excited about Buffalo selecting Shaq Lawson

    I do not give much energy to the notion of value for a pick or the virtues of consensus on a pick. If either was truly worthwhile the first round hiring tournament would do better than a 50% hit rate. I do pretty well looking at occasional highlights on youtube and reading between the lines of scouting overviews available online.

    For example I spotted Kirk Cousins watching five minutes of a game his senior year. Same with Kevin Hogan this year. I also knew to stay away from Todd Collins from watching the end of a comeback attempt his senior year. I miss sometimes, but with QBs and top tens less than Kiper.

    I have seen the highlights on Lawson. He reminds me a lot of Marcell Dareus without the occasional explosive quickness. I would be as upset as I was with the Dareus pick if they had taken him third (because while I think both are good I don't think they are difference-makers waiting to happen) but they didn't, did they? He went 19th, and with the rookie wage scale that is a moderate investment. I don't mind having him, so long as he isn't used in pass coverage too often. I think he is an adequate tackler, and I think he will be a good player. If Buffalo is lucky he will be as good as Phil Hansen. I don't think he will be as good a pass rusher as Aaron Schobel, but I think he will be productive. Is he going to be better than Jarius Wynn? Maybe, but not by a whole lot. Wynn is a solid pro who doesn't lose his one on one battles too often. He also doesn't make game-changing plays. Will Lawson? Occasionally. Is that worth 3M per year or whatever it is the 19th slot is guaranteed and almost guaranteed playing time? Maybe. I don't know.

    Working things out here, please be patient a bit longer.

    For me it comes down to the guys who were available. Among those who went earlier, I would have been happier to get Floyd, Rankins, Pothead, Stanley, and know nothing of Buckner or Conklin. I would have been as happy to get Apple or Kelly.

    Of the guys they left behind there are a bunch (like, 30 at various positions) I think are equivalent to Lawson, but the ones I rate higher (and by that I mean I think they will be better at their position in the NFL) are: Kenny Clark, maaaaaybe Nkemdiche, Spence, Sheldon Day, and Braxton Miller. So, for my team I want best available UNLESS I either value a position more than another or have something in place in terms of cost, fit, and production that I expect to keep the new guy on the bench for more than a year. In Buffalo that takes Spence out of the first round, because I expect Hughes to be around three more years. Miller plays a position I value less than DL, so he moves back into the same group as Lawson. I am ambivalent enough about Nkemdiche that I will never feel badly if he turns into a Hall Of Famer (in large part because I don't think he would in Buffalo, for whom I project a slide and another three years of tumultuous mediocrity due to bad coaching and resource management.) I think Day and Clark will be more disruptive. I have Dareus who is good, Williams who is great but old and breaking down, and Corbin Bryant who is OK. I don't think Day or Clark will be as good as I thought Aaron Donald was going to be, but this is the 19th pick.


    So, I would have preferred Day or Clark, but am satisfied that at least they didn't blow it. Ahem Raiders, Falcons, Bucs, and Jags.
    Last edited by ScottDCP; 04-29-2016 at 11:41 AM.
    Go, Flaming Thumbtacks!

  2. #2
    I was surprised you didn't go QB. One of the few weaknesses on the Bills

  3. #3
       
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    Rochester, NY
    Posts
    4,586
    Blog Entries
    21
    Pass rush, linebacker apart from Manny Lawson, and secondary where we are injury-prone. All worse than Taylor. A QB in the first three rounds this year is a bad bet. Even if they get a guy who could one day play, I expect the current coaching staff to misuse him, and the next to dump him. Better to go with the current starter, who is not bad.
    Go, Flaming Thumbtacks!

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •